Autoclaving slurries of porous, inorganic oxide particles results in an increased abrasiveness of the particles as reflected in increased removal rates of a polished substrate at standard polishing conditions in chemical mechanical polishing operations. Slurries having novel abrasion properties, especially for silica-based slurries, are created. The increase in particle abrasivity strongly correlates with a decrease in particle surface area as determined by N.sub.2 adsorption (BET method). As a result, methods for obtaining a desired abrasivity for a slurry can be practiced by heating a slurry of inorganic oxide particles to a BET surface area previously identified as associated with the abrasivity desired. The resulting slurries can be used in conventional polishing machinery. The method is particularly suitable for preparing silica-based abrasive slurries.